Best Baits for Croaker Fishing

Atlantic croaker are caught with a variety of cut baits. Top baits may vary widely depending on location and season. Some baits seem to work in almost any situation, while others are for specific situations.

In most areas, squid is the most common bait for catching croakers. Squid (calamari) is widely available, inexpensive and catches a variety of species.

Small boxes of squid are available in grocery stores, seafood markets are tackle shops. The quality of grocery store squid is not as high as bait quality squid but it does work in a pinch.

The best squid for catching croakers is caught locally and specially packaged for fishing. These squid are usually larger, tougher and whiter than calamari.

Bloodworms are another excellent bait for catching croakers. These large saltwater worms bleed profusely when cut up, which helps to attract fish. Bloodworms have an impressive mouth, armed with 4 sharp fangs. They can and will bite unwary anglers. Removing the mouth before cutting up the worm is usually the best approach.

Bloodworms are usually fished in small sections on a top and bottom rig. In areas where spot, pigfish or other small species are mixed in with croaker, bloodworms may be well worth the expense.

In areas such as the Chespeake Bay, peelers or shedder crabs are the best bait for catching croakers. These popular baits are Atlantic blue crabs which are almost ready to shed their shells.

Fresh shrimp are also popular for catching croaker, especially in southern areas. Shrimp is readily available, inexpensive and easy to use.

A variety of other natural baits are sometimes used for catching croakers, especially where local conditions warrant a specific bait. These may include sea clams, quahog clams, minnows, and other baits.

A number of synthetic baits are effective for catching croakers. These baits have several advantages. Most do not require refrigeration or special storage. The come in a wide range of shapes, scents, colors and patterns. Some are molded into strip baits for bottom fishing while others are shaped like bait species and can are suitable for casting, trolling, drift fishing, or jigging.